Blindness and Betrayal: A Disturbing Case of Domestic Violence in China

A shocking case in China has drawn widespread attention, where a 29-year-old woman, known as Xiaoxue, was brutally assaulted by her husband, Xie, just two months into their marriage. The attack, which was sparked by Xiaoxue's refusal to recharge her husband's online gaming account, left her blind and unable to care for herself. Xie was subsequently arrested, tried, and sentenced to 11 years in prison, with an additional order to compensate Xiaoxue with approximately 656,798.52 yuan.

Background Image

22 February 2025

The case began when Xiaoxue and Xie married in 2023, after meeting through a relative's introduction in 2022. Initially, Xie presented himself as a responsible and caring individual, often helping to take care of Xiaoxue's grandfather, which earned him the family's trust and affection. However, soon after their marriage, Xie's behavior took a drastic turn, becoming fixated on online gaming and repeatedly asking Xiaoxue for money to fund his gaming habits. Despite his lack of employment and contribution to the household, Xie managed to extract a significant amount of money from Xiaoxue, totaling 120,000 yuan, which was part of the 300,000 yuan given by his family for their marriage and housing expenses.

The situation escalated on March 19, 2023, when Xie demanded 10,000 yuan from Xiaoxue for gaming purposes. Upon being told that she had no more money to give, Xie became enraged and violently attacked Xiaoxue, punching her and causing her to bleed profusely from the nose. The assault continued with Xie using a frying pan to knock Xiaoxue unconscious. In a horrific turn of events, when Xiaoxue's cousin arrived at their residence, he found Xie attempting to strangle Xiaoxue with her pajama pants, having to intervene to stop the assault and call for emergency services.

扬子晚报
Fri Feb 21 22:46:14 +0800 2025
【#女儿遭家暴失明妈妈自责同意其闪婚##遭家暴失明女子在等伤残鉴定#】2023年3月,95后女孩小雪与丈夫谢某结婚仅两个月,因未给丈夫的游戏充值,遭到对方用拳头、平底锅击打至昏迷,随后又用睡裤勒颈至窒息,造成小雪双目失明并失去自理能力。同年12月,谢某被正式逮捕。2024年8月,法院一审判定谢某犯故意杀人罪,判处有期徒刑十一年,并责令谢某在判决生效后十日内赔偿小雪人民币656798.52元。随后,小雪的父母向检方申请抗诉。2025年1月17日,该案二审在法院开庭审理。2月21日,扬子晚报/紫牛新闻记者从小雪的母亲李女士处获悉,郑州市中级人民法院对该案作出终审裁定,驳回了上诉,维持了一审的原判。因没给丈夫游戏充钱女子新婚两个月被殴打小雪今年29岁,来自内蒙古。2022年8月,通过亲戚介绍,她认识了大其三岁的谢某。小雪的母亲李女士告诉扬子晚报/紫牛新闻记者:“介绍人当时告诉我们,谢某是个木匠,有一门手艺,家庭条件也还不错。”在两人恋爱期间,谢某的表现非常好,经常帮助照顾小雪的姥爷。小雪的姥爷因脑血栓而无法说话,谢某经常在他面前表现,赢得了老人的喜爱。李女士说:“老人已经八十多岁了,非常疼爱小雪。我想,如果能让小雪早点结婚,也算是完成了老人的一桩心愿。因此,我们就这样仓促地让他们结婚了,我现在真的非常自责。”尽管双方了解不多,但小雪和谢某在相处了5个月后,还是决定领证结婚。李女士补充说:“谢某当时喜欢玩游戏,我女儿因此和他吵过几次,但我们认为这不是一个大问题。”李女士向记者透露,当时谢家给了她女儿和谢某30万元,这笔钱是用来装修旧楼房以及作为结婚的各种开销,包括购买家具家电、拍摄婚纱照和办理酒席等费用。“那笔钱是给了他们两个的,存了起来,银行卡由我女儿保管。但从那以后,谢某既没有出去工作,也没有赚钱,反而一次次向我女儿要钱,我女儿给了他12万,这都是有记录可以查的。”李女士说,家里原本有一台台式电脑,谢某还是向她女儿要了一万五千元买了台笔记本电脑,但谢某仍然经常去网吧玩游戏,曾多次夜不归宿。李女士说,婚后谢某对网络游戏的迷恋更加严重,不断向小雪要钱,用于游戏充值。婚后不久,小雪和谢某商量着去海南打工。他们听说小雪的表哥在河南做游戏直播,收入不错,因此决定先去河南了解一下情况。“我女儿跟着她表哥学了两天,觉得还成。但谢某还是想去海南打工,就留我女儿在河南。当时我女儿还给了他5000块钱买机票,哪知道他去了三天就说没活干,又回来了。”李女士向记者回忆,2023年3月19日,两人结婚才两个月,谢某又一次向小雪索要1万元。小雪告诉谢某,自己已经没有钱了。谢某听后非常愤怒,对小雪挥拳相向,打得小雪鼻血直流。李女士说:“他用拳头打我女儿,之后还用平底锅把我女儿打晕。”当小雪的表哥赶到他们的住处时,看到谢某正骑在小雪身上,用睡裤死死勒住她的脖子。小雪的表哥立刻冲上前去,阻止了谢某的行为,并随即拨打了120急救电话。小雪被紧急送往郑州大学第五附属医院进行抢救。谢某离开现场后于当日到公安机关投案。二审维持原判男方获刑11年李女士告诉扬子晚报/紫牛新闻记者,在得知消息后,她立刻从内蒙古的老家赶到河南。“看到女儿的那一刻,我的心都要碎了。”李女士说,当时小雪的情况非常危急,在ICU里待了四个月才苏醒。医生的诊断表明,小雪因颅内出血导致视神经萎缩,从而双目失明。此外,她的身体还遭受了多处严重伤害,失去生活自理能力。2023年12月,小雪的伤情报告显示损伤程度为重伤一级,谢某被正式批捕。2024年8月30日,河南省郑州市中原区人民法院判决:一、谢某犯故意杀人罪,判处有期徒刑十一年。二、谢某于判决生效后十日内赔小雪人民币656798.52元。随后,小雪的父母向检方申请抗诉。2025年1月17日,该案件进行了二审开庭审理。2月17日,郑州市中级人民法院对该案作出了终审裁定,驳回了上诉,并维持了一审的判决。法院认为,被告人谢某故意非法剥夺他人生命,其行为已经构成了故意杀人罪。一审法院在判决时已经充分考虑了被告人系犯罪未遂、主动投案以及垫付部分医疗费用等法定和酌定的从轻情节,因此判处其有期徒刑十一年是适当的。原审判决认定的事实清楚,证据确凿、充分,定罪准确,量刑以及确定的民事赔偿数额均适当。审判程序合法。李女士向记者透露,在一审庭审时,谢某承认曾用平底锅打击小雪,共计四五次,并表示自己的行为构成故意伤害,但否认故意杀人,声称他并未想要杀害小雪。然而,在二审期间,谢某突然翻供,否认曾用平底锅打击小雪。在二审庭审现场,李女士质问谢某:“我女儿好好地嫁给你,她身上的伤病是谁造成的?是你吧?”谢某虽然承认了,但没有说一句道歉的话。女方双目失明,生活不能自理家属正申请伤残鉴定李女士说,为了维持后续的康复治疗,小雪想要拿回属于自己的财产,可没想到,连小雪自己名下的车都被谢某偷偷过户给了他的母亲。“出事以后,谢家不管不问,在派出所的强制要求下才拿出3.6万元医疗费。因为谢某名下没有资产,所以民事赔偿部分也很难执行。”“自此女儿出事,我们为了给她治病,卖掉了老家的房子和地,还向亲戚朋友借了很多钱。”李女士带女儿辗转多家医院,治疗费用超过一百多万元,但得到的答复都是视神经萎缩不可逆,小雪只能回家休养。李女士告诉记者,由于脑部缺氧缺血,小雪至今全身无力,加上双目失明,小雪的生活完全无法自理,不仅走路需要父母搀扶,甚至连吃饭的力气都没有。李女士向记者透露,由于之前的一些客观原因,小雪一直没有进行伤残鉴定。“我们已经提交了伤残鉴定的申请,目前正在等待排期。我们咨询了律师,如果伤残鉴定结果显示为六级,那么可能会影响到谢某的刑罚,每提高一级伤残等级,谢某的刑期可能会增加一到两年。”李女士表示,她将向法院申请再审。“我女儿的后半生都被毁了,她才29岁,现在不仅眼睛看不见,话也说不清楚。我每天都在家里照顾她,哪个母亲看到这样的情况不心疼?她是我身上掉下来的肉啊。”刑事案件终审后还能申请再审吗?伤残鉴定结果是否会影响被告的刑期?知名律师、河南泽槿律师事务所主任付建认为《刑事诉讼法》第二百五十三条规定了当事人及其法定代理人、近亲属的申诉符合下列情形之一的,人民法院应当重新审判:(一)有新的证据证明原判决、裁定认定的事实确有错误,可能影响定罪量刑的;(二)据以定罪量刑的证据不确实、不充分、依法应当予以排除,或者证明案件事实的主要证据之间存在矛盾的;(三)原判决、裁定适用法律确有错误的;(四)违反法律规定的诉讼程序,可能影响公正审判的;(五)审判人员在审理该案件的时候,有贪污受贿,徇私舞弊,枉法裁判行为的。如果小雪的伤残鉴定结果能够达到六级及以上,属于能够影响到量刑以及裁判结果的情形。伤残等级越高意味着犯罪行为人的主观恶性大、造成的损害后果严重。此时的伤残鉴定结果属于有新证据证明原判决事实有误可能影响量刑情形,可以向法院申请再审。扬子晚报/紫牛新闻记者万惠娟图片视频素材受访者提供剪辑戴哲涵Post picture
218
16

Xiaoxue was rushed to the hospital for emergency treatment and was later found to have suffered severe injuries that left her blind and unable to care for herself. Xie turned himself in to the authorities on the same day. The incident led to Xie's arrest in December 2023, and in August 2024, he was sentenced to eleven years in prison for intentional homicide, with an order to compensate Xiaoxue 656,798.52 yuan within ten days of the judgment taking effect.

Xiaoxue's family remains unsatisfied with the verdict, citing the severity of her injuries and the need for further compensation. The family has since applied for a reassessment of Xiaoxue's injuries, hoping that a more severe classification of her condition will lead to a harsher sentence for Xie. During the trial, Xie initially admitted to using a frying pan to hit Xiaoxue but later recanted his statement, denying the use of the frying pan. This contradiction in his testimony highlights the complexity and severity of the case.

The court's decision to uphold the original sentence underscores the seriousness with which the judicial system views such violent crimes, especially those resulting in severe and lasting harm to the victim. Xiaoxue's current condition is dire, with her being completely dependent on her parents for daily care due to her blindness and physical incapacitation. Her family is currently in the process of applying for a disability assessment, which could potentially impact Xie's sentencing if the results indicate a higher level of disability than initially assessed.

According to legal experts, new evidence such as a higher disability rating could be grounds for appealing the verdict, as it directly influences the severity of the crime's consequences and, by extension, the appropriateness of the sentence. The application of legal principles in this case reflects a system that endeavors to balance punishment with rehabilitation and victim compensation, aiming for a just outcome that reflects the true extent of the harm caused.

扬子晚报
Fri Feb 21 19:16:35 +0800 2025
【#女儿遭家暴失明妈妈自责同意其闪婚##遭家暴失明女子在等伤残鉴定#】2023年3月,95后女孩小雪与丈夫谢某结婚仅两个月,因未给丈夫的游戏充值,遭到对方用拳头、平底锅击打至昏迷,随后又用睡裤勒颈至窒息,造成小雪双目失明并失去自理能力。同年12月,谢某被正式逮捕。2024年8月,法院一审判定谢某犯故意杀人罪,判处有期徒刑十一年,并责令谢某在判决生效后十日内赔偿小雪人民币656798.52元。随后,小雪的父母向检方申请抗诉。2025年1月17日,该案二审在法院开庭审理。2月21日,扬子晚报/紫牛新闻记者从小雪的母亲李女士处获悉,郑州市中级人民法院对该案作出终审裁定,驳回了上诉,维持了一审的原判。李女士向记者透露,由于之前的一些客观原因,小雪一直没有进行伤残鉴定。“我们已经提交了伤残鉴定的申请,目前正在等待排期。我们咨询了律师,如果伤残鉴定结果显示为六级,那么可能会影响到谢某的刑罚,每提高一级伤残等级,谢某的刑期可能会增加一到两年。”李女士表示,她将向法院申请再审。“我女儿的后半生都被毁了,她才29岁,现在不仅眼睛看不见,话也说不清楚。我每天都在家里照顾她,哪个母亲看到这样的情况不心疼?她是我身上掉下来的肉啊。”(记者万惠娟剪辑戴哲涵)“女子新婚两月遭丈夫家暴致失明案”二审维持原判:男方犯故意杀人罪获刑11年扬子晚报的微博视频
4502
399

Xiaoxue's mother, Mrs. Li, expressed her deep dissatisfaction with the current verdict, stressing that the consequences of the husband's actions are severe and long-lasting. She highlighted the importance of the upcoming disability assessment for Xiaoxue, which could potentially impact the husband's sentence. The case has raised significant concerns about domestic violence, the legal system's response to such crimes, and the support available to victims.

As the family waits for the disability assessment results, they are preparing for a long and challenging journey ahead, both in seeking justice and in helping Xiaoxue cope with her new reality. The case serves as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of domestic violence and the imperative for vigilance and action to prevent such tragedies. The outcome of Xiaoxue's story will be closely watched, both as a test of the legal system's commitment to justice for victims of domestic violence and as a beacon of hope for those suffering in silence.

Share this article

Related Articles