Do Idols Really Need Acting Skills?
The debate about whether idols need acting skills has once again taken center stage, thanks to comments from netizens and fans of popular dramas. At the heart of this conversation is the performance of idols turned actors in television dramas and films. Some argue that idols, with their existing fanbase and popularity, can naturally draw in viewers, thus making their acting abilities less of a concern. Others passionately disagree, suggesting that acting is a skill that requires dedication, training, and talent, and that simply being an idol does not qualify someone to be a good actor.
17 March 2025
A recent example that caught the attention of many was the reaction to the acting of certain idols in the drama "Hush, the King is in Hibernation." Fans praised the emotional depth some idols brought to their roles, with scenes that showcased their characters' vulnerability and strength. For instance, a pivotal scene where the female lead, played by an idol, calls out for her companion, evoking a mix of emotional responses from the audience. The simplicity yet profoundness of this moment silenced critics, proving that when given the right role and direction, idols can indeed deliver impactful performances.
However, not all are convinced. Some point out inconsistencies in plot development and character movement, questioning the logic behind certain scenes. This lighthearted take on a potentially criticized scene underscores the flexibility of audience interpretation and the subjective nature of evaluating acting performances. The interchange on social media, filled with various analyses and personal experiences, reflects the broader public's engagement with the issue, raising important questions about talent, effort, and the role of celebrities in the entertainment industry.
Singer-songwriter Xu Song posted a cryptic message on social media, which many interpreted as a veiled commentary on the state of the entertainment industry and the type of talent it fosters. Meanwhile, a fan account dedicated to Ning Yizu and Giselle enthusiastically celebrated the beauty and presumably the talents of Ning Yizu, suggesting that physical appearance and possibly fan enthusiasm could outweigh acting prowess in the idol's repertoire. These online interactions reflect the diverse perspectives within the Chinese entertainment community, highlighting the complex interplay between talent, popularity, and the evolving role of idols in the industry.
The notion that idols don't need acting skills has been challenged by recent performances of certain idols, such as Tan Jianci and Bai Jingting, who have impressed fans and critics with their acting abilities. A fan of Tan Jianci expressed enthusiasm on social media, stating that having an actor like Tan Jianci in the entertainment industry is a blessing. Another fan took to social media to praise Bai Jingting's acting skills, unilaterally declaring him the "acting emperor" of idols. A video clip posted by a user further underscores the impressive acting abilities of certain idols, showcasing exceptional talent and authentic performances.
The recent statement by Liu Yuning that ancient costume dramas do not require acting skills has sparked a heated debate among audiences. Many have taken to social media to express their opinions, with some defending the skills of their favorite idols and others criticizing the lack of talent in the industry. One fan praised Xiao Zhan's acting skills, saying that he can bring any character to life with just one glance. On the other hand, a user took a more literary approach, writing a lengthy and poetic essay that explored the themes of memories, nostalgia, and the passage of time.
The finer details in dramas have been a subject of discussion among audiences, with many praising the acting skills of White Jingting and Zhang Ruonan. In a recent episode, the character of Wen Yifan, played by White Jingting, is seen having a heartfelt conversation with his love interest, played by Zhang Ruonan. The scene has left many viewers in tears, with one fan commenting on the emotional depth brought to the scene by the two actors. The dedication to their craft and the ability to convey nuanced emotions have made White Jingting and Zhang Ruonan stand out, dispelling the notion that present-day actors lack the necessary acting chops.
The online community has been abuzz with the topic "Who Says Idols Don't Need Acting Skills?", with many netizens expressing their opinions and reactions. Some users jokingly mentioned that the hashtag seems to be tailored for a specific "difficult" celebrity, implying that only such a figure could warrant such a trending topic. Another user shared a video on Weibo, discussing a collaborative project between two celebrities, complimenting one's abstract approach and the humorous, yet difficult-to-watch, moments in the video. These interactions showcase how netizens engage with trending topics, often blending serious opinions with humor and personal anecdotes.
Ultimately, the argument of whether idols need acting skills might be secondary to the more significant consideration of how talent, regardless of its origin, is nurtured and valued within the entertainment industry. As fans and critics alike continue to weigh in, it's clear that the conversation is far from over, and the performances of idols in dramas will remain under scrutiny. The exceptional performances by talented actors have not only engaged audiences but have also ignited a conversation about the value of acting skills in contemporary dramas. As the industry continues to evolve, it is clear that talented actors will remain at the forefront, moving and inspiring audiences with their craft.
Comments
