Neighborhood Dispute Erupts Over Taiwanese Celebrity's Ashes

The controversy surrounding the placement of Taiwanese celebrity Barbie Hsu's, also known as 大S, ashes in her home has sparked a heated debate. According to reports, her sister, Dee Hsu, also known as 小S, had initially announced that she would not hold a funeral service for her sister and instead planned to permanently place her ashes in their family home. However, this decision was met with dissatisfaction from their neighbors, who expressed their discontent on social media.

Background Image

7 February 2025

One neighbor, who claimed to live in the same building as 大S, wrote an angry post criticizing 小S for being "selfish" and "disregarding the anxiety of other residents" in the building. The neighbor argued that since 小S loved her sister so much, she should have placed her ashes in her own home instead of their shared residence. The neighbor also complained that the presence of ashes in the building would affect the quality of life for other residents.

小S later clarified through her agent that her sister's ashes were only temporarily placed in their home, pending the approval of a tree burial. 小S stated that her sister had always wanted an environmentally friendly tree burial, and they were currently in the process of applying for it. Once the application is approved, they would return her sister's ashes to nature.

申度新闻
Fri Feb 07 18:10:18 +0800 2025
【#老人吵架后去世邻居被判赔偿#法院:邻居承担5%赔偿责任】因邻居把建筑垃圾堆在公共部位,年过七旬的张阿伯(化名)与邻居争吵起来。谁知吵完架刚回到家门口,张阿伯就倒下了,送医后仍不治身亡,直接死因为急性心梗。张阿伯的家人遂将邻居诉至上海嘉定法院,索赔近60万元。法院认为,根据村委会工作人员的证言,张阿伯倒地之前曾与邻居沈阿婆(化名)发生过争吵,而发生争吵的起因是被告沈阿婆家在村委会多次要求下未主动拆除旧房围墙,在村委会工作人员上门拆除时,原、被告两户原本已就拆除围墙以及双方都不允许在两家相邻的弄堂堆放东西或者使用弄堂达成协议,但沈阿婆仍强行将村委会工作人员拆除围墙的砖头拿走,并堆放在原、被告两户弄堂中间,行为显然不当。虽现无证据证明沈阿婆对于张阿伯患有心脏病的情况知情,但原、被告两家系多年邻居,张阿伯已过七旬,从一般理性人角度出发,沈阿婆应当认识到激烈争吵对老年人带来的情绪激动以及一系列可能的法律后果,但仍与张阿伯发生争吵,未尽到一般人审慎注意义务,存在过失。其次,张阿伯直接死亡原因为急性心梗,其发病时间是在与沈阿婆刚刚争吵完毕,可以确认双方的争吵行为导致本身患有心脏病的张阿伯情绪激动、病情发作,与张阿伯的死亡之间存在法律上的因果关系,沈阿婆应当承担相应的侵权责任。再次,张阿伯与沈阿婆并无身体接触,正常情况下其吵闹行为不会导致张阿伯发生生命危险,虽然沈阿婆言行不当存在过错,但本身不具有侵害张阿伯生命的故意,张阿伯死亡的主要原因还是在于其自身疾病。且张阿伯明知自己存在既往高血压、心脏病病史应该避免情绪激动,但仍与沈阿婆争吵,对死亡后果,张阿伯自身存在主要过错,应减轻沈阿婆的赔偿责任。综合本案实际情况,法院酌情判令沈阿婆对张阿伯的损失承担5%的赔偿责任。除律师费、精神损失费由沈阿婆全额承担外,其余各项损失由沈阿婆承担5%。最终,法院判决沈阿婆赔偿原告张阿伯的家人4万余元。详见视频:申度新闻的微博视频
73
35

As news of the controversy broke, netizens took to social media platforms to share their thoughts and opinions. Some users expressed sympathy for 小S's decision, while others echoed the concerns of the neighbors, who felt that the ashes should not be kept in a residential area. The hashtag #大S邻居不满小S将姐姐骨灰放家中 quickly went viral, with many users weighing in on the issue. Some argued that it was a personal choice and that 小S had the right to decide where to keep her sister's ashes, while others felt that it was not suitable to keep human remains in a home, especially in a densely populated area.

小鸡呀天
Fri Feb 07 22:34:23 +0800 2025
#S家已经给大S申请树葬#大S邻居喊话小S自私。S家把大S骨灰放家里引邻居不满,在网上愤慨发文喊话小S:“公众人物就那么自私的公开要把亲人的骨灰放置家中?完全无视社区大楼住户的不安。S家亲友团透露正在帮大S申请树葬,待申请会把她的骨灰回归大自然。#张兰回应黑粉#Post picture
2793
275

In a recent development, the controversy has been alleviated with the announcement that 大S's family will opt for a tree burial. This decision was confirmed by 小S, who revealed that the family is currently processing the application for the tree burial. According to 小S, this decision was in line with 大S's own wishes, and the family is working diligently to ensure that the process is carried out with respect and dignity. The tree burial decision is a welcome resolution to the dispute that had been brewing among the residents of the luxury apartment complex where 大S's family resides.

芒果捞小萌主
Fri Feb 07 19:33:10 +0800 2025
#大S邻居不满小S将姐姐骨灰放家中##邻居不满大S骨灰放家中#大S骨灰放家中,邻居不满发声:无视住户不安,并喊话小S:为什么不放你自己家?Post picture
92003
4022

The decision to proceed with a tree burial has been met with relief and understanding, as it is seen as a more harmonious and respectful way to handle the situation. Tree burials are becoming increasingly popular in Taiwan as an eco-friendly alternative to traditional burials, and it is hoped that this decision will bring closure and peace to all parties involved, including 大S's family, friends, and the residents of the apartment complex. The tree burial decision is not only a testament to the family's commitment to respecting 大S's wishes but also a reflection of the growing trend towards more environmentally conscious and sustainable funeral practices.

新浪娱乐
Fri Feb 07 22:25:12 +0800 2025
#小S证实大S将树葬#据台媒,大S骨灰放在家中一事引发争议。刚刚,小S通过经纪人发声证实大S将树葬,“因为其实我们每次聚餐的时候,都一定会聊到生死的话题,然后每个人都会有自己的想法,记得当时我姐姐说,如果她有一天走了,她想要环保树葬,所以我们现在正在申请当中,我姐的骨灰是先暂放在温暖的家中。等到申请到了,我们就会把我亲爱姐姐的骨灰回归大自然。”#S家已经给大S申请树葬#Post picture
46748
2320

Share this article

Related Articles