News & Politics

Nitrogen Execution: A New Method of Capital Punishment

The Use of Nitrogen in Executions: A New Development in Capital Punishment

Background Image

1 February 2024

The recent execution of Kenneth Smith in Alabama marked the emergence of a wholly new method of capital punishment, the use of nitrogen. Smith was sentenced to death for his involvement in a murder case that took place in 1988 and this execution marks the first time that nitrogen gas has been used as a method of execution in the United States.

Smith was executed using a process that involves the inhalation of a high concentration of nitrogen, causing the individual to immediately suffer from oxygen deprivation. This method is considered to be a more humane alternative to traditional methods of execution, such as lethal injection or the firing squad. However, it has been met with controversy and skepticism from some corners of society.

One user on Weibo, commenting on the execution, stated that "对大奸大恶之人应该以其人之道,还治其人之身。道理是不错,但谁去执行呢,该怎么落实?" which translates to "For those who commit great evil, they should be punished in the same way they punished others. This makes sense, but who will execute it and how?". This user raises questions about the practicality and effectiveness of this method in terms of punishment for those who have committed heinous crimes.

Another user, @0o秋水op, commented that "千刀万剐那种最好" which translates to "The best punishment would be to be put through a thousand cuts." This user expresses a preference for more painful methods of execution, arguing that this would serve as a greater deterrent for potential criminals.

This issue has also been discussed on social media in China, with one user stating that "一些网友认为对大奸大恶之人应该以其人之道,还治其人之身,道理是不错,但谁去执行呢,该怎么落实?现实角度来讲有难度呀,但不这样又觉得他们死的太轻松了" which translates to "Some netizens believe that for those who have committed great crimes, they should be punished in the same way they punished others. This makes sense, but who will execute it and how? From a practical perspective, it's difficult. However, if we don't do this, it feels like they die too easily." This highlights the complexities that are involved in determining the most appropriate method of execution for those who have committed grave crimes.

Similarly, another user lamented that the nitrogen execution method "这个主要过程比较痛苦,可能还有不丝的风险,还要再来一遍" which translates to "This process is mainly quite painful, and there may still be risks, and it may need to be repeated." This user highlights the potential issues that this method may present, raising concerns about the effectiveness of this method in terms of both deterrence and punishment.

As the debate around the use of nitrogen in executions continues, it is clear that there are numerous opinions and concerns about this method. Some argue that this method is more humane and should be used as a means of execution, while others express concerns about the practicality and effectiveness of this method in terms of punishment and deterrence.

Concluding, it is evident that the use of nitrogen in executions is a complex issue that is currently being discussed and debated on social media platforms in China. The method has its supporters and detractors, and it is likely that this debate will continue to unfold in the coming months and years.