Pregnant Woman Hit by Falling Luggage on Train, Sparks Safety Concerns and Calls for Accountability

The incident of a pregnant woman being hit by a falling luggage on a high-speed train, resulting in premature birth and the subsequent death of the baby, has raised concerns about the handling and accountability of such events. According to reports, the pregnant woman, surnamed Zhang, was traveling on the D3702 train from Foshan West to Chongzuo when a luggage suddenly fell from the luggage rack and hit her abdomen. Despite seeking medical attention immediately, Zhang's baby was born prematurely and unfortunately passed away two days later.

Background Image

19 February 2025

The incident has sparked heated discussions online, with many calling for improved safety measures on trains, particularly for pregnant passengers. The lack of adequate storage space for luggage on trains has been cited as a contributing factor to the incident. Legal experts have weighed in on the issue, suggesting that both the railway authority and the owner of the luggage may be liable for compensation. According to Article 823 of the Civil Code, the carrier is responsible for compensating passengers for personal injuries or death during transportation, unless the injury or death is caused by the passenger's own health conditions or intentional or gross negligence.

In this case, the injury was not caused by the passenger's own health conditions or other personal reasons, and therefore, the carrier should be held responsible for the damages. If the owner of the luggage had placed the luggage in accordance with railway regulations and did not exhibit any negligence, they may not be held liable. However, if the luggage exceeded the weight limit or was placed in a manner that did not comply with regulations, the owner may also be held partially responsible.

_企鹅糕
Wed Feb 19 14:39:50 +0800 2025
#12306回应孕妇被行李箱砸中致早产#动车高铁上的大件行李存放处真的很少,有的车子连前后排座位后面的位置都没了,大件行李箱只能放在架子上或者放在身侧,要是不怕丢就放在门口或者餐车,一点也不方便。什么时候能多一些大件行李存放处啊,学生和旅行的人真的很需要啊!_企鹅糕的微博视频

The railway department and the luggage owner have been passing the buck, with each party claiming that the other is responsible for the incident. The woman has stated that she has found the luggage owner, but they are also denying responsibility. The investigation into the incident is being handled by the Guangzhou Railway Bureau, with a lawyer commenting on the legal implications of the incident. The lawyer stated that if the luggage owner had placed the luggage properly, they may not be liable for compensation, but if the railway department failed to take adequate safety measures, they may be held responsible for the incident.

极目新闻
Wed Feb 19 10:00:49 +0800 2025
#12306回应孕妇被行李箱砸中致早产#【孕妇自称在动车上被行李箱砸中腹部,导致孩子早产离世,铁路方回应】#孕妇称在动车上被行李箱砸中致早产#近日,网友张女士在社交媒体上反映,1月22日自己在动车上被突然掉落的行李箱砸中腹部,导致孩子早产离世。据网传信息,1月22日,张女士乘坐D3702次列车,在南宁东至南宁站区间,被行李架上突然掉落的行李箱砸中腹部。她随后在南宁站下车,步行出站打车前往南宁妇幼保健院检查,做了胎心监护和B超,发现胎盘早剥、胎盘血窦,有先兆早产的风险。张女士表示,因情况危急,1月23日上午她进行了剖宫产手术,11时13分宝宝出生,“因为是超早产宝宝,一出生就被送进了新生儿科。从出生开始,宝宝一直处于被救治状态。直到25号上午9时,宝宝永远地离开了我。”张女士介绍,关于行李箱的掉落问题,目前铁路方和行李箱所有人仍未划清各自责任。南宁市妇幼保健院的工作人员介绍,入院后张女士做了剖宫产手术,然而不幸的是,后来孩子未能保住。南宁铁路12306客服告诉极目新闻记者,D3702次列车从佛山西站开往崇左南站,由广州铁路局负责运营。“已经有人反映此事,我们已经记录,广州铁路局已有相关工作人员正在处理。”广州铁路12306客服则表示,他们暂不掌握该情况。#律师解读火车行李坠落致孕妇早产#孕妇自称在动车上被行李箱砸中腹部,导致孩子早产离世,铁路方回应极目视频的微博视频
54564
2648

The incident highlights the need for improved safety measures on trains, particularly for vulnerable passengers such as pregnant women. It also underscores the importance of clear regulations and guidelines for luggage storage on trains, as well as the need for railway authorities and passengers to take responsibility for ensuring safety on board. The case is ongoing, and it remains to be seen how the railway authority and the owner of the luggage will be held accountable for the incident. However, one thing is clear: the safety of passengers, particularly vulnerable ones, must be the top priority for railway authorities, and incidents like this must be thoroughly investigated and addressed to prevent similar tragedies from occurring in the future.

中国新闻周刊
Wed Feb 19 13:38:22 +0800 2025
【#孕妇被行李砸中孩子早产离世谁担责#】#车站回应孕妇被行李砸中孩子早产离世#近日,孕妇称乘坐动车被掉落的行李箱砸中腹部,致胎儿早产离世,引发社会关注。该网友发帖称,1月22号乘坐D3702次列车,在南宁东至南宁站区间,被行李架上突然掉落的行李箱砸中腹部,她提前在南宁站下车后,自行前往南宁妇幼保健院就医,因发现有先兆早产风险于次日进行剖宫产手术,婴儿超早产两日后不幸离世。#12306回应孕妇被行李箱砸中致早产#该网友称,事发至今铁路部门、行李主人均未主动联系本人,其多次向铁路部门联系,列车长回应称责任归属行李主人,行李主人回复称是铁路的责任,责任归属问题也未划分清楚。当事人回复网友留言时表示,“已找到(行李主人),但也是推卸责任,我们准备起诉了”。2月19日,南宁站相关工作人员告诉@中国新闻周刊,此事因发生在列车上,归属广州铁路局负责,据其了解,广铁集团已有人员处理此事。对于该网友称车站工作人员未提供医疗服务协助的情况,南宁站服务台工作人员表示,不清楚当天事发情况,但只要列车长提出,或乘客提出需求,服务台都会为重点旅客提供帮助。对于行李坠落致伤涉及的法律问题,陕西恒达律师事务所律师赵良善认为,鉴于目前权威机构还未给出调查结论,如果经调查,行李主人规范放置行李,即行李主人无过错的,则无需承担民事赔偿责任。相反,若未规范放置导致行李掉落,行李主人需承担一定的民事赔偿责任。而铁路方负有安全保障义务,若出现安全措施不到位,或允许不符合要求的行李箱带进车厢、未及时发现行李存在脱落风险等情形的,则视为铁路方未尽到安全保障义务,需承担一定的侵权赔偿责任。Post picture
95
22

The incident has sparked a heated debate about the responsibility of the railway department and the luggage owner. According to Article 823 of the Civil Code, the railway bureau, as the carrier, has a duty to ensure the safe transportation of passengers and guarantee their safety until they reach their destination. The fact that the passenger was injured by a falling luggage suggests that the railway staff failed to fulfill their obligation to inspect and eliminate the risks associated with improperly placed luggage. The luggage owner may also be liable for the incident if they failed to place the luggage properly, and the railway department may be held responsible if they failed to take adequate safety measures.

扬子晚报
Wed Feb 19 13:00:53 +0800 2025
【#医院回应哪吒宝宝出生#:手术适合早产儿分娩】#医护拆盲盒开出哪吒宝宝#2月16日,徐州和平医院一产妇先后降生一对龙凤胎,其中,男宝宝像哪吒一样是待在大“肉球”出生。手术医生刘成文介绍,产妇因突发情况紧急入院,医院经研判开展EnCaul剖宫产,在胎膜囊未破的情况下,完整地将胎儿及其附属物一并娩出,避免了气压骤变对未成熟器官的冲击,特别适合早产儿分娩。术中,第一名宝宝顺利被取出,接下来,医护人员开启了“拆盲盒”模式,这个大肉球的“水晶外壳”也被打开,是一名男宝宝。目前,这对龙凤胎和妈妈均平安。(记者马志亚剪辑戴哲涵)#江苏一龙凤胎出生时自带结界#徐州扬子晚报的微博视频

Ultimately, the incident serves as a call to action for societal reflection and improvement in safeguarding the well-being of pregnant women and their unborn children. It highlights the importance of a safe and respectful environment for all, particularly vulnerable individuals, and the need for increased awareness, responsibility, and support for pregnant women. The discussion also extends to the readiness of medical facilities in handling such emergencies, emphasizing the role of innovative medical techniques and the training of medical staff in ensuring the best possible outcomes for both mothers and babies.

潇湘晨报
Wed Feb 19 12:05:32 +0800 2025
#12306回应孕妇被行李箱砸中致早产#【#律师谈孕妇被箱子砸致孩子离世##妇联回应孕妇被箱子砸致孩子离世#】近日,有网友在社交媒体上反映,1月22日她在动车上被突然掉落的行李箱砸中腹部,最后导致孩子早产离世。2月19日,南宁市妇联的工作人员告诉@潇湘晨报记者,已经收到了当事人朋友的求助,已经向其解释了法律层面的问题。目前,具体情况他们还在了解中,若情况属实,会关注、跟进的。知名律师河南泽槿律师事务所主任付建告诉潇湘晨报记者,他认为,铁路局和行李人可能需要承担侵权责任。根据《民法典》第八百二十三条规定客运合同中的旅客人身伤亡责任,承运人应当对运输过程中旅客的伤亡承担赔偿责任;但是,伤亡是旅客自身健康原因造成的或者承运人证明伤亡是旅客故意、重大过失造成的除外。本次伤害,并非是当事人本人健康原因或者其他自身原因造成的,承运人应当对当事人的损害承担责任。乘坐火车时应遵守安全员的引导进行安检、有序乘车、放置行李。如果行李放置人按照铁路局的相关规定放置了行李,那么行李人没有过错,则不需要承担责任。但是如果行李人的行李超重,或者有其他不符合规定的行为,则行李人也要承担部分侵权责任。当事人可以先和铁路局协商,也可以拨打12306客服电话进行反映,协商不成只能向法院起诉,要求其承担相应的赔偿责任。网传信息显示,1月22日,该网友乘坐D3702次列车,从桂平开往崇左,在南宁东至南宁站区间,被同一车厢旅客行李架上突然掉落的行李砸中腹部。列车长没有帮忙联系救护车,也没有询问是否中途下车,而是广播寻医。最后该网友在医生乘客的陪同下,车站工作人员没有帮忙叫救护车也没有安排其出站,他们步行出站后打车前往南宁妇幼儿童保健院。医院检查结果是胎盘早剥,胎盘血窦,有先兆早产风险,医院建议马上住院保胎。1月23日早上做完B超后医生建议马上破腹产,于是11点,该网友进行了剖宫产手术,13分钟后宝宝出生。出生开始宝宝就一直在救治状态,2天后,25日早上九点宝宝去世。该网友还称,事发至今,铁路部门、行李主人没有过联系。她多次和双方联系,双方却互相推诿责任。19日,据极目新闻,南宁市妇幼保健院的工作人员介绍,入院后张女士做了剖宫产手术,然而不幸的是,后来孩子未能保住。工作人员还提到,张女士已经出院。南宁铁路12306客服告诉极目新闻记者,D3702次列车从佛山西站开往崇左南站,由广州铁路局负责运营。“已经有人反映此事,我们已经记录,广州铁路局已有相关工作人员正在处理。”南宁潇湘晨报的微博视频
91
22

Share this article

Related Articles