Scoring Scandal Sparks Outrage: 'Black Curtain' Chants Erupt on Chinese Variety Show
A shocking incident recently unfolded during the recording of the popular variety show "Cheng Feng Po Lang" (Ride the Wind and Break the Waves), leaving both the audience and contestants stunned. The controversy centered around the low scores given to Wu Xuan Yi's team, which sparked widespread discontent among the live audience. Despite receiving high praise from the audience for their outstanding performance, Wu Xuan Yi's team was unexpectedly ranked near the bottom with a score of 668, prompting the crowd to erupt in chants of "black curtain" (a Chinese idiom for "scandal" or "rigging").
2 April 2025
The audience's strong reaction was fueled by the perceived disconnect between the team's impressive performance and their low ranking. Many felt that the scoring was unfair and that Wu Xuan Yi's team was robbed of a higher ranking. The incident has sparked a heated debate on social media, with fans and viewers expressing their disappointment and outrage using hashtags such as #全场都在喊黑幕 (the whole audience is shouting "black curtain"). Some have suggested that the audience's reaction may have been influenced by the fact that many of them were fans of Wu Xuan Yi, and therefore felt that she deserved a higher ranking.
Wu Xuan Yi's team performance was indeed exceptional, with the crowd thrilled by their energetic and cohesive show. Wu Xuan Yi, known for her powerful vocals and captivating stage presence, had been a standout throughout the competition. Her team's performance had the crowd on their feet, with many chanting "black box" or "黑幕" in protest of the perceived injustice of their low scores. The discrepancy between the audience's enthusiasm and the judges' scores has sparked heated debate among fans and raised questions about the fairness and transparency of the competition's judging process.
The controversy surrounding the event has raised significant questions about the fairness and transparency of the show's judging process. Some viewers claim that Wu Xianyi's team was unfairly given low scores due to behind-the-scenes manipulation, while others believe it was a legitimate outcome of the competition. The crux of the controversy lies in the significant disparity between Wu Xianyi's team's on-stage performance and their final ranking, leaving many viewers perplexed and dissatisfied. The intense debate has ignited a heated discussion on social media, with many fans and netizens demanding greater transparency and fairness in the judging process.
The incident highlights the challenges in balancing the need for entertainment with the requirement for fairness in competitive programming. It also underscores the significant influence of audience perception and the importance of transparency in the judging process to maintain the credibility of such shows. The controversy has had a considerable impact on the "Cheng Feng Po Lang" program and its fans, raising questions about fairness and transparency. Addressing these concerns and ensuring transparency and fairness in the competition process is crucial for maintaining the program's integrity and the loyalty of its fan base. Ultimately, the incident has sparked a broader discussion on judging criteria and fairness in competitive shows, emphasizing the need for transparent and equitable treatment of all participants to maintain the program's credibility.
