Shenzhen Parents Debate Volunteer School Gate Duty Amid Safety and Convenience Concerns

Many parents in Shenzhen are required to take turns volunteering at their children's schools, ensuring the safety of students during rush hours. Some parents believe that this practice is necessary due to the poor road conditions and heavy traffic in the area. They highlight its importance in emergency situations where parents can step in to help. On the other hand, some parents argue that the responsibility can be a burden, as many parents have their own work commitments and may not be able to spare the time.

The discussion has also spilled over to online platforms, with netizens weighing in on the matter. Some parents have suggested that the duty should be replaced with paid staff or volunteers who can devote more time and attention to the task. Others have proposed alternative solutions, such as enlisting the help of other law enforcement agencies or introducing volunteer teams to assist with traffic management. However, there are also parents who support the existing system, arguing that it is a small price to pay for the safety of their children and that it helps to foster a sense of community and social responsibility among parents.

Lawyers have weighed in on the issue, stating that schools are not allowed to compel parents to participate in volunteer activities, and that any such activities should be truly voluntary and without coercion. In response to the proposal, the Shenzhen Education Bureau has emphasized the importance of voluntary participation, stating that parents who volunteer can receive certificates of service. The bureau also announced plans to implement improvements, including a voluntary duty system and digital management of parental volunteer services.

As the city weighs the pros and cons of this issue, several possible solutions have emerged. One potential solution is to introduce a paid traffic management system, where trained professionals are hired to oversee traffic safety around schools. This approach would not only ensure the safety of students but also provide a steady income for the individuals employed. Additionally, the city could explore alternative models, such as partnering with private companies to provide traffic management services or implementing intelligent transportation systems that minimize the need for human intervention.

Shenzhen officials have indicated a willingness to consider alternative approaches, exploring ways to optimize traffic management around schools, including the use of technology and innovative solutions. While no concrete decisions have been made, it is clear that the city is committed to finding a solution that balances the needs of parents, students, and the community at large. The debate highlights the challenges of balancing school safety with the needs and constraints of working parents, and it remains to be seen how the city will address the concerns of parents while ensuring the safety and well-being of students.