THE9 Under Fire for Underage Drinking, Sparking Debate on Celebrity Autonomy
A recent incident involving Chinese boy group THE9 has set off a heated discussion on social media, with many fans and netizens weighing in on the topic of underage drinking. The group, which consists of nine members born between 1998 and 2002, was spotted drinking what appeared to be beer or other alcoholic beverages, sparking both criticism and support from fans.
29 August 2024
Some fans defended the group, pointing out that they are now young adults and should be allowed to enjoy a drink or two. "They're no longer the cute, innocent kids they used to be," wrote one fan on Sina Weibo. "It's natural for them to want to try new things, including drinking." Industry insiders also noted that the entertainment industry often lacks fresh and lively people, and this incident highlights the need for idols to be able to express themselves more authentically.
On the other hand, some netizens expressed concern over the group's behavior, citing worries about the negative influence on their younger fans. "As role models, they should be more mindful of their actions," wrote another user. "Drinking is not something that should be encouraged or promoted, especially among minors." However, others argued that THE9, as a group of young adults, should be granted some degree of autonomy.
The differing reactions highlight the complex relationship between celebrities and their fans in the age of social media, where every move is scrutinized and every personal choice is subject to public opinion. While some have condemned the behavior, others have come to their defense. "Yesterday, it was 'returning to their mothers' in the entertainment industry, today it's being criticized for being a grown adult and having a drink," wrote one commenter on social media, highlighting the hypocrisy in the public's expectations of the group.
Die-hard fans have been thrilled to see a more relaxed and carefree side of THE9. One fan account even jokingly called out the group for being caught drinking, saying "You've been discovered! As punishment, you have to film a drunk video for us!" The fan's tongue-in-cheek comment was accompanied by a video clip that showed a member of the group playfully stumbling around, eliciting squeals of delight from fans.
The controversy has sparked a wider debate about the pressures and expectations placed on celebrities, particularly those in the entertainment industry. "Why can't they just be themselves and have a little fun?" asked one fan. "They're constantly under scrutiny and pressure to maintain a perfect image. It's exhausting just watching them." The incident has also raised questions about the sustainability of the idol image and the pressure it puts on celebrities to conform to unrealistic expectations.
Ultimately, the decision to drink or not is a personal one, and THE9's choice to enjoy a drink in private should not be subject to excessive scrutiny. However, as public figures, they must also consider the impact of their actions on their fans and the wider community. As the debate continues, one thing is clear: the lines between idol and individual are increasingly blurred, and the public's expectations of their behavior are evolving.